• Yet Another Google Pay Fail



    Okay, this is getting a bit ridiculous... after years of complaining about tap and pay on Android I finally have a OnePlus phone with a decent NFC radio and a stable version of Magisk that successfully hides root from Google's official tap and pay app.

    And it still doesn't work.

    Shame on me, I guess, for thinking I could use it with my AMEX card at a shop where AMEX isn't accepted. Since Google obfuscates your credit card number from the merchant I assumed that the type of credit card would similarly be hidden; I was wrong. I realize that it's only a matter of time until tap and pay finally starts working as promised, but this latest experience has me questioning yet again if I should even bother.

    Let's revisit the three pillars of Google Pay:

    Security
    Again, Google Pay hides my credit card number from the retailer, but here in Canada credit cards use Chip and PIN security which yields, for the user, pretty much the same result.

    Convenience
    Google Pay does at least let me leave my credit and debit cards at home, so if I get a hankering for Peanut M&Ms when I'm out getting exercise then I'm covered. But most of the time I carry my phone in my oversized wallet, so the value for me is dubious at best.

    Offers
    Google Pay is supposed to alert me of nearby offers as I make my way through the world. For the past week in downtown Toronto the number of said offers has been zero.

    I'm starting to wonder if the only real perk of using Google Pay is that Google gets to see all of your transactions on any registered card, whether you're using Google Pay or not. Is there something I'm missing here?

    ---------
    This article was originally published in forum thread: Yet Another Google Pay Fail started by acurrie View original post
    Comments 10 Comments
    1. zapjb's Avatar
      zapjb -
      Google detects your phone doesn't have enough telemetry connected to their servers & your phone is blocking ads. So no Google Pay for you.
    1. SoNic67's Avatar
      SoNic67 -
      Not to worry, Magisk has the CC numbers now.
    1. acurrie's Avatar
      acurrie -
      Quote Originally Posted by zapjb View Post
      Google detects your phone doesn't have enough telemetry connected to their servers & your phone is blocking ads.
      And that would explain why I'm not getting any offers... Hadn't thought of that; thanks!
    1. NGeorge's Avatar
      NGeorge -
      Using Google or Apple Pay or any other NFC payment product will not change the network your payments go over. If itís an AmEx, itís an AmEx no matter if itís the physical card or loaded in your phone ó if the shop doesnít take AmEx, no amount of hiding the number will make it happen. The stores dictate which networks their credit card readers will process payments on. The readers can tell this by the numbers ó note how (at least in the US) Visa cards start with 4, Mastercard with 5, Discover with 6, and AmEx 3 or 4 and is only 15 instead of 16 digits.

      Now, occasionally a store will ďsayĒ they donít take AmEx, or only post Visa/Mastercard in the window, and actually take it anyway, but thatís the exception not the rule. As a heavy AmEx user, I find that I just use it first everywhere ó maybe about 25% of stores without AmEx in the window still take it ó otherwise they donít and I use the backup Visa.

      Unfortunately there is no way to make your AmEx not an AmEx

      N
    1. NGeorge's Avatar
      NGeorge -
      Using Google or Apple Pay or any other NFC payment product will not change the network your payments go over. If itís an AmEx, itís an AmEx no matter if itís the physical card or loaded in your phone ó if the shop doesnít take AmEx, no amount of hiding the number will make it happen. The stores dictate which networks their credit card readers will process payments on. The readers can tell this by the numbers ó note how (at least in the US) Visa cards start with 4, Mastercard with 5, Discover with 6, and AmEx 3 or 4 and is only 15 instead of 16 digits.

      Now, occasionally a store will ďsayĒ they donít take AmEx, or only post Visa/Mastercard in the window, and actually take it anyway, but thatís the exception not the rule. As a heavy AmEx user, I find that I just use it first everywhere ó maybe about 25% of stores without AmEx in the window still take it ó otherwise they donít and I use the backup Visa.

      Unfortunately there is no way to make your AmEx not an AmEx

      N
    1. brad4cell's Avatar
      brad4cell -
      Amex charges more so that is why some shops don't accept it. Often small businesses won't take amex but most large businesses will.

      So just use another credit card. Most people with amex have another card.

      As for the Google pay that I never used so don't know much about it but I don't see much advantage over just using a credit card.
    1. californiajay's Avatar
      californiajay -
      Google Pay, and Apple Pay in my opinion are just another example of the high tech world in that which we live that do things just because "they can" rather than for any real practical benefit. For me, it actually seems much quicker and easier to just take a card out of my wallet and pay with it. The ONLY plus I can see is that by leaving all cards at home, you may be at less risk of losing a card here or there or having its magnetic strip or chip data stolen as you are much less likely to hand your phone over to a waiter who then might go to some other room to make the payment.
    1. turbogeek's Avatar
      turbogeek -
      Maybe it's just me, but I consider not receiving offers (i.e. additional geo-targeted [intrusive] advertising) a good thing.
    1. AlexKidd1977's Avatar
      AlexKidd1977 -
      Quote Originally Posted by NGeorge View Post
      Unfortunately there is no way to make your AmEx not an AmEx
      It sounds to me like he was expecting it to work more like PayPal where they transact cash from the AmEx card into the balance and then simultaneous transfer the money directly to the merchant on their own network.

      Merchants sometimes take PayPal but they wouldnít prefer it at all because the fees are overall a lot higher so I donít expect any solution like that to get traction.

      óKidd
    1. acurrie's Avatar
      acurrie -
      Guys, guys, I did the thing:

      Attachment 162689

      Attached my VISA card to Google Pay, used it at a location where VISA was accepted. Girlfriend captured the moment for posterity.

      And only 7 and a half years since my last successful mobile NFC payment!
  • Sponsored By

  • Facebook

  • Recent Reviews

  • Recent Forum Posts

    cougar11

    Visible $40 a Month

    Anyone in this wireless service? Sorry if it is on the wrong thread but didn't find a Visible Wireless section.

    I'm currently on ATT prepaid, paying $45 a month ( with autopay), is it worth...

    cougar11 Today, 09:08 AM Go to last post
    DennyT

    Why return it? From what coldknob said in his...

    Why return it? From what coldknob said in his post, you get the same result whether you get the separate airtime card or activate the new pre-loaded sim. Unless I'm missing something.

    DennyT Today, 09:01 AM Go to last post
    arxaw

    I have had this same problem in the past on an...

    I have had this same problem in the past on an ASUS tablet that doesn't have a SIM inserted.
    I solved it by: Long-press the app icon> Select "App Info"> "Force Stop."

    arxaw Today, 08:05 AM Go to last post
    bradpgh47

    This is the first 5G node in Pittsburgh located...

    This is the first 5G node in Pittsburgh located at the intersection of Schenley Drive Extension and Forbes Ave. It is directed at the Schenley square park across from hillman library at the...

    bradpgh47 Today, 07:58 AM Go to last post
    DRNewcomb

    I guess I just have to accept this because I...

    I guess I just have to accept this because I don't know enough about the subject to engage in a debate. I had a pretty good handle on GSM but LTE is a whole different animal. I'd still like to see a...

    DRNewcomb Today, 07:40 AM Go to last post