• What's the Deal with Fitbit?

    So last Thursday San Francisco-based Fitbit filed for a $100 million IPO on the New York Stock Exchange. Good for them. But in this age of Android Wear and Apple Watch someone's going to have to explain to me why their products continue to be so popular. For me the most vexing of all is the $250 USD Fitbit Surge™ you see above. It supports notifications so it's technically a smartwatch, but it does hardly anything else that you'd expect a smartwatch to do.

    I guess I don't really need an explanation; I know full well that Fitbit has become a generic term associated with fitness tracking, like Kleenex and Q-tips® for the things that they do. I also know that part of Fitbit's appeal is the smartphone app and online account that you get with every device, so that you can track your fitness and compete with your friends.

    But you know these things aren't accurate, right?

    A BBC Click presenter did a group test of activity trackers earlier this year. Here's what she had to report about her experience with them:

    I've spent a full week wearing four of the latest and best-known trackers to see if they all came up with the same results. My findings? They don't.

    At their worst, one day saw a variation between them of 23% in distance covered, and over the course of a week a difference in opinion between the Fitbit Charge and Jawbone Up Move of 2,649 calories burned - that's more than an entire day's calorie intake for someone of my build.
    Fitness tracker manufacturers will all say that the numbers themselves are less important than the patterns they generate. I suppose I can accept that, to a point... Because I've also seen with my own eyes someone add a couple of steps to their Fitbit's step-count just by flicking their wrist.

    Look, I'm not going to knock anyone for wearing an fitness tracker if it gets them thinking about being more active. I just know that for the money there are far better choices—cough cough, Pebble, cough—than a Fitbit.

    Unless there's something else I'm missing...?

    This article was originally published in forum thread: What's the Deal with Fitbit? started by acurrie View original post
    Comments 4 Comments
    1. seneschal's Avatar
      seneschal -
      They're pretty cheap and easy to use, and prompt you to get off your butt.
      They sync to Bluetooth automatically and have a slick website to show you what's going on.
      The point is not the accuracy of 23% or less, but to motivate you to move around.

      I prefer my Fitbit One instead of a watch because you don't even feel it's there.
    1. acurrie's Avatar
      acurrie -
      Quote Originally Posted by seneschal View Post
      I prefer my Fitbit One instead of a watch because you don't even feel it's there.
      And here's the link: Fitbit® One™

      It's certainly very different from your typical smartwatch; thanks for the comment!
    1. lmcjipo's Avatar
      lmcjipo -
      I have a Fitbit Charge HR which I purchased in the US before it became available in Canada and I really like it. The battery lasts for ~4 days based on my usage and for the most part, it is fairly accurate in terms of what I can tell for my sleep and resting heart rate.
    1. acurrie's Avatar
      acurrie -
      And I'm guessing BlackBerrry support (via Amazon) was a factor in your purchase?
  • Sponsored By

  • Facebook

  • Recent Reviews

  • Recent Forum Posts


    I've just switched my personal line from cricket...

    I've just switched my personal line from cricket to AT&T prepaid. My other 4 lines are still with cricket 4 for 100. I was thinking of switching them too, but 2 of the phones that are on the account...

    buglewe Today, 03:50 AM Go to last post

    Don't know if you've done this, but go back to...

    Don't know if you've done this, but go back to the SIM Status screen, and once there, scroll down on the screen to see if the ICCID number shows up.

    That's what I have to do on my phone to see...

    frankelstein Today, 03:14 AM Go to last post

    LTE-M for texting?

    Are there any LTE-M devices on the market that would enable humans to text? i.e. with a keyboard and some type of screen?

    dajs Today, 03:06 AM Go to last post


    What flavour of LTE-M is Telus using, and with which frequency bands?

    Do you need a special contract to access it or would it work with a Telus prepaid or a Koodo prepaid SIM? (assuming you had a...

    dajs Today, 03:04 AM Go to last post

    I would like that. :-)

    I would like that. :-)

    dajs Today, 01:48 AM Go to last post